| Career Passing Yards |
| 1. Brian Dawson |
10,257 (1999-2002) |
| 2. Pete Coughlin |
9,993 (2013-16) |
| 3. Bobby Swallow |
9,020 (2005-08) |
| 4. Chris Edwards |
8,303 (2002-05) |
| 5. Jacob Pugh |
7,668 (2021-24) |
| Career Passing Touchdowns |
| 1. Bobby Swallow |
104 (2005-08) |
| 2. Brian Dawson |
100 (1999-2002) |
| 3. Pete Coughlin |
95 (2013-16) |
| 4. Jacob Pugh |
93 (2021-24) |
| 5. Chris Edwards |
87 (2002-05) |
| Â Â Â Â Jason Baer |
87 (1993-96) |
| Single-Season Passing Yards |
| 1. Bobby Swallow |
3,778 (2008) |
| 2. Chris Edwards |
3,450 (2005) |
| 3. Chris Edwards |
3,307 (2004) |
| 4. Jacob Pugh |
3,282 (2024) |
| 5. Kellan Stahl |
3,275 (2025) |
| Single-Season Passing Touchdowns |
| 1. Bobby Swallow |
46 (2007) |
| 2. Jacob Pugh |
40 (2024) |
| 3. Chris Edwards |
38 (2004) |
|   Jacob Pugh |
38 (2023) |
| 5. Bobby Swallow |
37 (2008) |
| Single-Season Pass Completions |
| 1. Bobby Swallow |
295 (2008) |
| 2. Pete Coughlin |
273 (2014) |
| 3. Pete Coughlin |
243 (2016) |
| 4. Jacob Pugh |
242 (2024) |
| 5. Kellan Stahl |
240Â (2025) |
| Single-Game Passing Yards |
| 1. Jacob Adams |
499 (vs Westminster, 10/26/19) |
| 2. Alex Rowse |
482 (vs Thomas More, 09/16/17) |
| 3. Pete Coughlin |
473 (vs Brockport State, 11/18/16) |
| 4. Jacob Adams |
432 (vs Geneva, 10/13/18) |
| 5. Chris Edwards |
419 (vs Allegheny, 9/17/05) |
| 6. Chris Edwards |
418 (vs Bridgewater, 11/20/04) |
| 7. Kellan Stahl |
408 (vs Waynesburg, 10/25/25) |
| 8. Bobby Swallow |
405 (vs Oberlin, 9/22/07) |
| 9. Jacob Pugh |
396 (vs Grove City, 9/30/23) |
| 10. Jacob Adams |
392 (vs Waynesburg, 11/11/17) |
| Longest Pass |
| 1. Jacob Adams to Cameron O'Brien |
94, at Carnegie Mellon (2019) |
| 2. Chris Edwards to Mike Virgin |
91, at Waynesburg (2003) |
| 3. Brian Dawson to Toddy Fry |
90, vs. Allegheny (2001) |
| 4. Bobby Swallow to Tom McCafferty |
89, at Saint Vincent (2007) |
| Brian Dawson to Todd Fry |
89, at Buffalo State (2000) |
| 6. Chris Locher to Ryan Silvis |
81, at Thiel (2000) |
| Â Â Â Â Rich Riotto to Jim Greaves |
81, at Bethany (1985) |
| Career Rushing Yards |
| 1. Chris Babirad |
5,714 (1989-92) |
| 2. Joey Nichols |
4,833 (1999-2002) |
| 3. A.J. Pagano |
3,697 (1984-87) |
| 4. Jake Williams |
3,633 (1993-96) |
| 5. Ryan Mendel |
3,243 (2003-06) |
| Single-Season Rushing Yards |
| 1. Chris Babirad |
2,471 (1992) |
| 2. Chris Babirad |
1,713 (1991) |
| 3. Ryan Ruffing |
1,605 (2014) |
| 4. Joey Nichols |
1,577 (2001) |
| 5. Joey Nichols |
1,460 (2002) |
| Longest Rush |
| 1. Jordan West |
98, vs. Case Western Reserve (2018) |
| 2. Roger Snyder |
90, vs. Allegheny (2000) |
| 3. Chris Babirad |
88, at Waynesburg (1991) |
| 4. Larry Pitts |
87, vs. Waynesburg (1990) |
| 5. Jason Barr |
84, at Waynesburg (1997) |
| Â Â Â Â A.J. Pagano |
84, at Juniata (1984) |
| Career Total Touchdowns |
| 1. Chris Babirad |
74 (1989-92) |
| 2. A.J. Pagano |
59 (1984-87) |
| 3. Ryan Ruffing |
56 (2012-15) |
| 4. John Peduzzi |
55 (2022-25) |
| 5. Jesse Zubik |
54 (2014-17) |
| Â Â Joey Nichols |
54 (1999-2002) |
| Single-Season Touchdowns |
| 1. Chris Babirad |
34 (1992) |
| 2. Ryan Ruffing |
29 (2014) |
| 3. Dion Wiegand |
25 (2013) |
| Â Â Â Â Curt Jones |
25 (2008) |
| 5. Ryan Ruffing |
22 (2015) |
| Â Â Â Â Chris Babirad |
22 (1991) |
| Career Scoring |
| 1. Chris Babirad |
446 (1989-92) |
| 2. A.J. Pagano |
361 (1984-87) |
| 3. Ryan Ruffing |
336 (2012-15) |
| 4. John Peduzzi |
330 (2022-25) |
| 5. Joey Nichols |
326 (1999-2002) |
| Single-Season Scoring |
| 1. Chris Babirad |
204 (1992) |
| 2. Ryan Ruffing |
174 (2014) |
| 3. Curt Jones |
156 (2008) |
| 4. Dion Wiegand |
150 (2013) |
| 5. Chris Babirad |
134 (1991) |
| Career Receptions |
| 1. Jesse Zubik |
291 (2014-17) |
| 2. Alex Baroffio |
269 (2010-13) |
| 3. John Peduzzi |
250 (2022-25) |
| 4. Jacob Macosko |
209 (2022-25) |
| 5. David Ravida |
192 (2005-08) |
| Single-Season Receptions |
| 1. Jesse Zubik |
97 (2016) |
| 2. Todd Fry |
94 (2001) |
| 3. Alex Baroffio |
91 (2013) |
| 4. Craig Besong |
90 (2009) |
| 5. David Ravida |
86 (2008) |
| Single-Season Receiving Yards |
| 1. Todd Fry |
1,631 (2001) |
| 2. Ryan Silvis |
1,535 (2000) |
| 3. Jesse Zubik |
1,413 (2016) |
| 4. Jesse Zubik |
1,408 (2017) |
| 5. Andrew Wolf |
1,339 (2018) |
| 6. Jacob Macosko |
1,230 (2024) |
| 7. Craig Besong |
1,186 (2008) |
| 8. Jacob Shields |
1,135 (2004) |
| 9. John Peduzzi |
1,126 (2023) |
| 10. Alex Baroffio |
1,102 (2011) |
| Career Receiving Yards |
| 1. Jesse Zubik |
4,756 (2014-17) |
| 2. John Peduzzi |
4,168 (2022-25) |
| 3. Jacob Macosko |
3,234 (2022-25) |
| 4. Alex Baroffio |
3,203 (2010-13) |
| 5. Ryan Silvis |
3,155 (1997-2000) |
| Single-Season Receiving Touchdowns |
| 1. Andrew Wolf |
21 (2018) |
| 2. Ryan Silvis |
20 (2000) |
| 3. Jesse Zubik |
18 (2016) |
|   John Peduzzi    |
18 (2023) |
| 5. Jesse Zubik |
17 (2017) |
| 6. Craig Besong |
16 (2008) |
| 7. Aaron Krepps |
15 (2005) |
| Â Â Â Â Aaron Krepps |
15 (2004) |
| Â Â John Peduzzi |
15 (2025) |
| Career Receiving Touchdowns |
| 1. Jesse Zubik |
54 (2014-17) |
| Â Â Â Â John Peduzzi |
54 (2022-25) |
| 3. Andrew Wolf |
40 (2017-21) |
| 4. Aaron Krepps |
39 (2002-05) |
| 5. Jacob Macosko |
34 (2022-25) |
| Single-Season Total Offense |
| 1. Bobby Swallow |
3,760 (2008) |
| 2. Pete Coughlin |
3,562 (2014) |
| 3. Pete Coughlin |
3,486 (2016) |
| 4. Jacob Pugh |
3,436 (2024) |
| 5. Kellan Stahl |
3,403 (2025) |
| Single-Season All-Purpose Yards |
| 1. Chris Babirad |
2,711 (1992) |
| 2. A.J. Pagano |
2,132 (1987) |
| 3. Chris Babirad |
2,128 (1991) |
| 4. Dion Wiegand |
1,953 (2013) |
| 5. Aaron Krepps |
1,946 (2005) |
| Career Tackles |
| 1. Justin Johns |
362 (2020-24) |
| 2. Eric Field |
348 (2001-04) |
| 3. Craig Sedunov |
317 (2007-10) |
| 4. David Gitlitz |
316 (2005-08) |
| Jim Meyer |
316 (1985-87) |
| Single-Season Tackles |
| 1. Jared Pratt |
136 (2014) |
| 2. Jim Meyer |
131 (1987) |
| 3. John Glusica |
127 (1982) |
| 4. Shawn Prendergast |
124 (1992) |
| 5. Andy Shook |
118 (2004) |
| Â Â Â Â Eric Field |
118 (2003) |
| Career Sacks |
| 1. Stephan Swentkowsky |
43 (1988-90) |
| 2. Mark Kern |
34 (1985-88) |
| 3. Matt Szczypinski |
33 (1991-94) |
| 4. Shawn McGee |
32 (1990-93) |
| 5. Mike Brooder |
31 (1991-94) |
| 6. Dawson Dietz |
30.5 (2021-24) |
| Single-Season Sacks |
| 1. Mike Brooder |
17 (1994) |
| Â Â Â Â Shawn McGee |
17 (1993) |
| 3. Stephan Swentkowsky |
15.5 (1988) |
| 4. Jacob Bloomhuff |
14.5 (2009) |
| 5. Matt Szczypinski |
14 (1994) |
| Â Â Â Â Erik Franklin |
14 (1994) |
| Â Â Â Â Mark Kern |
14 (1987) |
| Career Tackles for Loss |
| 1. Mark Kern |
64.5 (1985-88) |
| 2. Matt Szczypinski |
62 (1991-94) |
| 3. Mike Brooder |
58 (1991-94) |
| 4. Dawson Dietz |
57 (2021-24) |
| 5. Stephan Swentkowsky |
56.5 (1988-90) |
| 6. Dan Primrose |
53 (1993-96) |
| Single-Season Tackles for Loss |
| 1. Matt Szczypinski |
29 (1994) |
| 2. Shawn McGee |
26 (1993) |
| 3. Mark Kern |
25 (1987) |
| 4. Stephan Swentkowsky |
24.5 (1988) |
| 5. Mike Brooder |
24 (1993, 1994) |
| 6. Dawson Dietz |
23.5 (2022) |
| Career Interceptions |
| 1. Frank Pilato |
18 (2001-04) |
| 2. Nick Cherish |
17 (2003-06) |
| 3. Dave Conn |
15 (1987-90) |
| 4. Gilbert Floyd |
15 (1988-91) |
| 5. O'Shea Anderson |
13 (2014-17) |
| 6. Steve Gulakowski |
12 (1982-85) |
| Single-Season Interceptions |
| 1. Rickey Williams |
10 (1992) |
| Â Â Â Â Mark Persichette |
10 (1975) |
| 3. O'Shea Anderson |
9 (2017) |
| 4. Nick Cherish |
8 (2006) |
| 5. Frank Pilato |
7 (2004) |
| Â Â Â Â Owen George |
7 (1999) |
| Â Â Bruno Fabrycki |
7 (2023) |
| Â Â Dante DeRubbo |
7 (2025) |
| Longest Field Goal |
| 1. John Ivory |
51, at Juniata (1988) |
| Â Â Â Â John Ivory |
51, at JCU (1988) |
| 3. Ted Bell |
50, vs. Grove City (1986) |
| 4. Ted Bell |
49, (1984) |
| 5. Ted Bell |
48, vs. Geneva (1984) |
| 5. Mike Evan |
48, (1995) |