| Name |
Sport |
Year |
| David Damico** |
Men's Basketball (3rd Team) |
1978 |
| David Damico** |
Men's Basketball (1st Team) |
1980 |
| Mike Pratt |
Men's Basketball (2nd Team) |
1981 |
| Gregg Ferrero** |
At-large/Wrestling (2nd Team) |
1986 |
| Tony Torchia |
Men's Basketball (2nd Team) |
1986 |
| Gregg Ferrero** |
At-large/Wrestling (1st Team) |
1987 |
| Tom Lapcevic |
At-large/Wrestling (1st Team) |
1987 |
| Alicia Allison |
At-large/Women's Tennis (2nd Team) |
1988 |
| Dave Conn** |
Football (2nd Team) |
1989 |
| Ken Jones |
Football (2nd Team) |
1989 |
| Michelle Rathgeb** |
At-large/Women's Tennis (2nd Team) |
1989 |
| Dave Conn** |
Football (2nd Team) |
1990 |
| David Branchen** |
Men's Basketball (2nd Team) |
1990 |
| Michelle Rathgeb** |
At-Large/Women's Tennis (2nd Team) |
1990 |
| Raymond Cross, Jr.** |
Football (2nd Team) |
1991 |
| David Branchen** |
Men's Basketball (3rd Team) |
1991 |
| Allison Evanoff** |
At-large/Cross Country (3rd Team) |
1991 |
| Raymond Cross, Jr.** |
Football (1st Team) |
1992 |
| Allison Evanoff** |
At-large/Cross Country (1st Team) |
1992 |
| Michael Jones** |
Football (1st Team) |
1993 |
| Michael Jones** |
Football (1st Team) |
1994 |
| Christopher Rihn** |
At-large/Men's Soccer (3rd Team) |
1994 |
| Christopher Rihn** |
At-large/Men's Soccer (3rd Team) |
1995 |
| Jaimee Heffner** |
At-large/Women's Track & Field (3rd Team) |
1998 |
| Carrie Banaszak |
Volleyball (3rd Team) |
1998 |
| Jennifer Baumgartel |
At-large/Cross Country (2nd Team) |
1999 |
| Jaimee Heffner** |
At-large/Women's Track & Field (2nd Team) |
1999 |
| Nemanja Kuzmanovic |
At-large/Men's Water Polo (3rd Team) |
2003 |
| Sam Mann |
Baseball (2nd Team) |
2007 |
| Matt Houy |
Football (2nd Team) |
2008 |
| Michael Grasso |
At-large/Men's Golf (3rd Team) |
2008 |
| Mitch Erdely |
Football (1st Team) |
2009 |
| Valerie Schultz |
Softball (2nd Team) |
2009 |
| Jessica Barby |
At-large/Women's Water Polo (3rd Team) |
2009 |
| Spencer Ahrenholtz |
Women's Soccer (3rd Team) |
2009 |
| Pat Kennedy |
Baseball (2nd Team) |
2010 |
| Sean Maddock |
Men's Soccer (2nd Team) |
2010 |
| Jessica Barby |
At-large/Women's Water Polo (1st Team) |
2010 |
| Shelby Colyer |
At-large/Field hockey (2nd Team) |
2012 |
| Josh Etzel** |
At-large/Wrestling (1st Team) |
2013 |
| Erin Barno |
At-large/Field Hockey (2nd Team) |
2013 |
| Josh Etzel** |
At-large/Wrestling (1st Team) |
2014 |
| Josh Staniscia |
Baseball (1st Team) |
2014 |
| Valerie Dunlap |
Women's Basketball (3rd Team) |
2015 |
| Nick Carr |
At-large/Wrestling (2nd Team) |
2015 |
| Chris DeNunzio |
At-large/Men's Water Polo (2nd Team) |
2015 |
| Ryan Doyle |
Football (2nd Team) |
2015 |
| Nicholas Willison** |
At-large/Men's Water Polo/Swimming (1st Team) |
2016 |
| Riley Groves |
Baseball (3rd Team) |
2017 |
| Nicholas Willison** |
At-large/Men's Water Polo/Swimming (1st Team) |
2017 |
| Harley Moyer*** |
Cross Country/Track & Field (3rd Team) |
2017 |
| Jesse Zubik        |
Football (2nd Team) |
2017 |
| Rachel Johnson** |
Softball (2nd Team) |
2018 |
| Harley Moyer*** |
Cross Country/Track & Field (3rd Team) |
2018 |
| Rachel Johnson** |
Softball (2nd Team) |
2019 |
| Rachel Buyan |
At-large/Field Hockey (3rd Team) |
2019 |
| Harley Moyer*** |
Cross Country/Track & Field (1st Team) |
2019 |
| Conor Manning |
Football (1st Team) |
2019 |
| Nate Wang |
At-large/Men's Tennis (3rd Team) |
2020 |
| Sean Doran** |
Football (2nd Team) |
2020-21 |
| Alex Keith*** |
Football (2nd Team) |
2020-21 |
| Tyler Horvat*** |
Baseball (2nd Team) |
2021 |
| Ben Peticca    |
Men's Golf (3rd Team) |
2021 |
| Parker Laughlin    |
Men's Cross Country & Track and Field (3rd Team) |
2021 |
| Sean Doran** |
Football (2nd Team) |
2021 |
| Alex Keith*** |
Football (2nd Team) |
2021 |
| Tyler Horvat*** |
Baseball (1st Team) |
2022 |
| Evan Sante** |
Baseball (1st Team) |
2022 |
| Maya Krishnasamy |
At-Large/Women's Tennis (3rd Team) |
2022 |
| Alex Keith*** |
Football (1st Team) |
2022 |
| Tyler Horvat*** |
Baseball (1st Team & Team Member of the Year winner) |
2023 |
| Evan Sante** |
Baseball (3rd Team) |
2023 |
| Cassie Carr** |
Women's Cross Country & Track and Field (3rd Team) |
2023 |
| Dawson Dietz** |
Football (2nd Team) |
2023 |
| Scout Zaas |
Baseball (1st Team) |
2024 |
| Ian Baughman |
Men's Cross Country & Track and Field (3rd Team) |
2024 |
| Cassie Carr** Â Â |
Women's Cross Country & Track and Field (2nd Team) |
2024 |
| Zach Cernuto |
Football (First Team) |
2024 |
| Dawson Dietz** |
Football (First Team) |
2024 |